February 13th, 2008
Broadway Stars: The Music of the Night by Matthew Murray
Matthew Murray of Broadway Stars writes:
As the Phantom, Anthony Crivello ranks among the best I’ve seen, and is certainly one of the scariest: He plays, more than anyone else, the frightened child trapped within the man’s twisted body, and stalks about the stage as a tortured mass of impetuous anger leavened only by the hope that love isn’t forever beyond his grasp. His falsetto renderings of his songs’ more tender passages (especially in “The Music of the Night”) are caressingly lovely, his booming threats startling with their intensity, and his final moments equally comical and pitiful, when so many actors lose them in the harried act of wrapping up the plot.
Crivello, shorn of that responsibility by the revisions that reduce the story to a bullet-point-riddled PowerPoint presentation, succeeds because of his fearlessness to plumb the depths of what makes men men. More than ever before, you see his Phantom as the alpha male to Raoul’s prim metrosexual, the natural force balancing out the miracle of modern engineering. It’s a battle that he’s not destined to win. And it turns out only slightly better for the Phantom presenting his gorgeous-looking but pared-down story to audiences traditionally more interested in the surface-over-substance issues the Phantom himself rails so violently against.

